Experts like Barbara Simons would rather disenfranchise some voters.

In a recent talk on internet voting in the Voting Village at DEF CON, Barbara Simons, Chair of the Verified Voting Board, faced a question from an overseas voter who lives in Mexico. The question was sincere: “I’m one of those 6 million voters who's a US citizen who lives overseas. I live in Mexico. Receiving or returning a ballot by any kind of postal mail is completely impractical. What do you suggest for these 6 million voters or do you just disenfranchise all of them?”

Unfortunately, Simons offered the questioner no real answer. First, she suggested he simply mail his ballot back the minute he received it - 45 days before an election. When he pointed out mail is so unreliable in Mexico that he would be forced to spend $65 to $75 to ship it back by DHL, she then stuttered her way until she revealed her real response: “Not everybody…”

Simons caught herself before finishing that sentence, but it was clear what she was about to say: Not everybody can vote

Now she didn’t actually say that. But her message did. She thought maybe a voter could take a ballot to an Embassy, or just return to the States to vote. But ultimately, it’s not a good choice to use unreliable mail vs online voting.

Simons, along with other experts like Andrew Appel, are outspoken critics of any attempt to offer online voting options to any voter. They’re also vehemently opposed to efforts to address security concerns with online voting, ignoring or publishing misleading or even disinformation about research and development projects designed to make online voting more secure.

Instead, they’d rather tell the voters who rely on these voting options in order to be enfranchised that they’re just out of luck. 

Are you a blind voter who can’t physically mark a paper ballot? They’d tell you that you can either have someone else mark your mail ballot for you - relinquishing your right to a secret ballot - or find your way to a polling place and hope that the accessible equipment is working.

If you have a disability, forget about traveling during an election. Experts like Simons expect you to be able to vote in person or not at all.

And if you’re serving in the military and you’d like to weigh in on important decisions, such as who will represent you in Congress or serve as the next Commander in Chief, you may just have to rely on mail finding you wherever you are stationed in the world. And if you want to vote, you’d better do it the second the ballot finds you.

Fortunately, online voting options are available to at least military and overseas voters in 32 states. Most of those states offer voters the ability to fax or email their ballots back. These are imperfect solutions that states have embraced because they recognize that it is truly a choice about access.

But that choice should not be so fraught. And experts like Simons and Appel should be working with election officials, technologists, and vendors to offer better solutions rather than settling for disenfranchising millions of American voters. They’re right to say email and fax return is vulnerable to hacking.  Other election security experts have acknowledged in the past that systems that enable voters to independently verify their ballots are securely cast and counted may help mitigate those risks. (See the U.S. Vote Foundation’s Future of Voting Report and Common Cause’s Email and Internet Voting Security Report.)

Security researchers have developed new tools, like VoteSecure, that can enable publicly verifiable online voting designed to make these voting options better and more secure without risking voter access. It’s time for experts like Simons and Appel to embrace real solutions that help protect voting access for all voters while ensuring the security of every ballot. 

In 2026, shrugging shoulders and telling voters they just don’t have a good solution is no longer good enough.

Next
Next

Statement from The Mobile Voting Project in Response to Supreme Court Ruling in U.S. Postal Service v. California Blocking Mail-In Ballot Restrictions For 2026 Midterms